11 responded to this post

mygif
 fowler. said on November 20th, 2005

no thanks, too many negative connotations with that image. seems like there’s an idea.. but, not quite there yet.

mygif
 Ganso said on November 20th, 2005

I disagre. I think the idea is well put and the pun is greatly done though I think the ad is a fake (I seriously doubt the american PC media would allow such ad).

mygif
 sanam said on November 20th, 2005

the ad would never fly, and I’m not sure that you want to be associating your lollipops with the taste of cigarettes, but it still made me smile.

mygif
 Martin said on November 20th, 2005

I like it. It tells me, as an millitant non-smoker, that you don’t have to smoke a cig to be cool. Thats a message, my kids should see. And I like the idea of spoofing Marlboro.
I think it’s a shame that this ad should be a fake. I’d love to see those in mags and on billboards…

mygif
 vanina said on November 20th, 2005

hm, the first think that came to my mind was “what? chupa chups produce cigarettes now?”
i definitely don’t like it.

mygif
 david_sa said on November 20th, 2005

Whos Chupa’s target market? Would they go buy Chupa when they see some ol cowboy on the ad? Don’t think so. And the tagline is weak. Not real ad, if its real the ceative should be punished. [spankinbuttock mode son]

mygif
 James Harrison said on November 21st, 2005

i think it’s funny for creatives, but there’s no way this would get past the horsing around side of a creative meeting. the main reason being, everyone who is 25 – 100 years old remembers those marlboro ads. this would be like cuppa chps advertising for marlboro. i see cigarettes before i see suckers.

mygif
 Mark said on November 21st, 2005

you seriously think this could be real? come on dude…

mygif
 Jexy said on November 21st, 2005

Its probably spec, but I reckon its good. Not brilliant, but good. I like the idea of appropriating and subverting advertising for products that have negative connotations.

mygif
 Anonymous said on November 23rd, 2005

I find it good (not great) in terms of design and cleverness, but A+ for the coverage (even negative) it generates. Efficient, it is.

mygif
 bdeth said on November 23rd, 2005

My first thought was, “where’s the joke” and I immediately looked at the SGW for some spoof copy. Not there.

Take away the warning spot to avoid temptation for an overly-done joke. Then I’d give it a B-

Leave A Reply

Go Back To Home |

 Name (*required)

 Email Address (*private)

 Website (*optional)

Please Note: Comment Moderation Maybe Active So There is No Need To Resubmit Your Comments